Compare Stamped.io vs Yotpo for reviews, loyalty, and more. Explore pricing, features, and integrations to find the ideal e-commerce marketing fit.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Ultimate Feature-by-Feature Comparison
Selecting the right customer engagement platform can make or break your e-commerce growth strategy. Stamped.io, Yotpo, and Maestra are three popular solutions that each tackle reviews, loyalty, and marketing in different ways.
Stamped.io—Best for small e-commerce businesses or early-stage brands that want an affordable way to leverage customer reviews and basic loyalty programs. Stamped focuses on building trust through user-generated content and repeat purchases. However, it doesn’t include advanced marketing automation or a built-in customer data platform, so you’ll eventually need other tools as you scale.
Yotpo—Best for e-commerce SMBs looking to harness UGC (user-generated content), customer reviews, and loyalty programs alongside basic email/SMS marketing. Yotpo’s strength is its broad suite of tools—reviews, loyalty, referrals, email, SMS—that work together to create a more holistic customer engagement strategy. That said, its personalization capabilities are limited (no native CDP), meaning you’ll rely on third-party integrations to truly unify customer data.
Maestra—Best for mid-market brands with an established marketing team and steady store traffic that need a unified marketing platform to drive growth through hyper-personalized promotions across all channels. Maestra is the most unified platform in this comparison, with a real-time CDP at its core and built-in tools for email, SMS, on-site personalization, loyalty, and more—all working seamlessly together. It’s designed for scaling companies that want to personalize marketing at every touchpoint without piecing together multiple tools.
In this in-depth comparison, we’ll evaluate them across key aspects. To make the insights easy to digest, we’ve structured the comparison with score table, concise explanations, and a final verdict. By the end, you’ll have a clear picture of each platform’s strengths and weaknesses—and which might be the best fit for your business.
Content:
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Comparison Summary
Feature
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
Omnichannel Flows
⭐⭐
Basic loyalty automations only; no cross-channel marketing flows built-in.
Basic loyalty automations only; no cross-channel marketing flows built-in.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Email & SMS included, but channels aren’t deeply unified without add-ons.
Email & SMS included, but channels aren’t deeply unified without add-ons.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Unified omnichannel campaigns (email, SMS, site, ads, etc.) driven by a real-time CDP.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Unified omnichannel campaigns (email, SMS, site, ads, etc.) driven by a real-time CDP.
Customer Data Management & Segmentation
⭐⭐
Basic customer lists and loyalty tiers; no CDP for advanced data unification.
Basic customer lists and loyalty tiers; no CDP for advanced data unification.
⭐⭐⭐
Basic customer profiles; Segments Plus for behavior-based grouping—but full CDP requires integration.
Basic customer profiles; Segments Plus for behavior-based grouping—but full CDP requires integration.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Built-in real-time CDP with rich profiles and advanced segmentation.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Built-in real-time CDP with rich profiles and advanced segmentation.
Site Personalization
⭐
None out-of-the-box (no personalized content; limited to displaying review widgets).
None out-of-the-box (no personalized content; limited to displaying review widgets).
⭐
None natively (would require an external personalization engine).
None natively (would require an external personalization engine).
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Real-time on-site personalization for each visitor using in-session data and segments.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Real-time on-site personalization for each visitor using in-session data and segments.
Email Marketing
⭐⭐⭐
Sends review requests and loyalty notifications; advanced campaigns require integration.
Sends review requests and loyalty notifications; advanced campaigns require integration.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Drag-and-drop email builder with basic AI recommendations; good for Shopify stores.
Drag-and-drop email builder with basic AI recommendations; good for Shopify stores.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Proprietary email composer with dynamic content per segment and AMP support.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Proprietary email composer with dynamic content per segment and AMP support.
SMS Marketing
⭐⭐
No native SMS (relies on third-party tools for texting customers).
No native SMS (relies on third-party tools for texting customers).
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Built-in SMS (via SMSBump) for carts, promos, reviews, etc., integrated with loyalty.
Built-in SMS (via SMSBump) for carts, promos, reviews, etc., integrated with loyalty.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Integrated SMS in omnichannel flows with bulk send, cross-device tracking, and A/B testing.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Integrated SMS in omnichannel flows with bulk send, cross-device tracking, and A/B testing.
Loyalty Programs
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Robust points, VIP tiers, and referral rewards to drive repeat business.
Robust points, VIP tiers, and referral rewards to drive repeat business.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Similar points, tiers, and referrals system; includes pre-built campaigns for quick start.
Similar points, tiers, and referrals system; includes pre-built campaigns for quick start.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Highly flexible loyalty & promotions engine (points, tiers, reactive offers) synced across channels.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Highly flexible loyalty & promotions engine (points, tiers, reactive offers) synced across channels.
Promotions & Referrals
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Rewards for referrals and basic promo codes; integrates reviews with loyalty for social proof.
Rewards for referrals and basic promo codes; integrates reviews with loyalty for social proof.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Time-sensitive referral campaigns and coupons; deeper integration with UGC for social promos.
Time-sensitive referral campaigns and coupons; deeper integration with UGC for social promos.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Dynamic promotions based on behavior (e.g. bonus points for high-value carts) + referral incentives, all omnichannel.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Dynamic promotions based on behavior (e.g. bonus points for high-value carts) + referral incentives, all omnichannel.
Product Recommendations
⭐
No built-in recommendation engine (would need a third-party app).
No built-in recommendation engine (would need a third-party app).
⭐
No native product recommendations (relies on external tools or Shopify apps).
No native product recommendations (relies on external tools or Shopify apps).
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
AI-driven product recommendations on site and email with 14 algorithms and real-time updates.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
AI-driven product recommendations on site and email with 14 algorithms and real-time updates.
Mobile & Web Push
⭐
Not supported natively (possible via external push notification services).
Not supported natively (possible via external push notification services).
⭐
Not supported natively (requires third-party push service).
Not supported natively (requires third-party push service).
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Built-in web and mobile push notifications with rich media, scheduling, and A/B testing.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Built-in web and mobile push notifications with rich media, scheduling, and A/B testing.
User-Generated Content
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Strong focus on product reviews (text, photo, video) to showcase UGC and build trust.
Strong focus on product reviews (text, photo, video) to showcase UGC and build trust.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Best-in-class UGC suite—review collection, Instagram curation, shoppable galleries, etc.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Best-in-class UGC suite—review collection, Instagram curation, shoppable galleries, etc.
⭐⭐⭐
No UGC management, but incentivizes reviews via loyalty rewards and post-purchase surveys.
No UGC management, but incentivizes reviews via loyalty rewards and post-purchase surveys.
Ad Optimization
⭐
No direct ad tools (can export reviews/ratings to ads manually; main focus is on-site engagement).
No direct ad tools (can export reviews/ratings to ads manually; main focus is on-site engagement).
⭐⭐⭐
Syncs reviews to Facebook & Google for social proof in ads; integrates with Ad platforms for dynamic ads.
Syncs reviews to Facebook & Google for social proof in ads; integrates with Ad platforms for dynamic ads.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Automatically builds ad audiences from segments and syncs to Google/Facebook, lowering acquisition cost.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Automatically builds ad audiences from segments and syncs to Google/Facebook, lowering acquisition cost.
Reporting & Attribution
⭐⭐⭐
Pre-built reports for reviews and loyalty (points earned, redemptions, NPS); CSV export available.
Pre-built reports for reviews and loyalty (points earned, redemptions, NPS); CSV export available.
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Dashboards for each product (loyalty, reviews, email) with metrics like conversion, sentiment, etc.
Dashboards for each product (loyalty, reviews, email) with metrics like conversion, sentiment, etc.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Unified analytics with goal tracking, campaign ROI, A/B test results, and industry benchmarks; export any data anytime.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Unified analytics with goal tracking, campaign ROI, A/B test results, and industry benchmarks; export any data anytime.
Customer Support
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Highly praised support team—very responsive even on lower tiers.
Highly praised support team—very responsive even on lower tiers.
⭐⭐⭐
Standard support via email/chat; dedicated CSM only on enterprise plans.
Standard support via email/chat; dedicated CSM only on enterprise plans.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
White-glove service for all: 5-min response, dedicated success manager for onboarding, strategy, and ongoing help.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
White-glove service for all: 5-min response, dedicated success manager for onboarding, strategy, and ongoing help.
Integration Capabilities
⭐⭐⭐
Dozens of integrations with e-commerce platforms (Shopify, BigCommerce, Magento) and key apps like Klaviyo.
Dozens of integrations with e-commerce platforms (Shopify, BigCommerce, Magento) and key apps like Klaviyo.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
170 integrations (ads, analytics, email, CRM, helpdesk, etc.) for broad connectivity.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
170 integrations (ads, analytics, email, CRM, helpdesk, etc.) for broad connectivity.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Open integration via API and webhooks + custom integrations built by your success manager as needed.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Open integration via API and webhooks + custom integrations built by your success manager as needed.
Educational Resources
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Knowledge base, support docs, and a blog with e-commerce marketing tips (Stamped “Learning” center).
Knowledge base, support docs, and a blog with e-commerce marketing tips (Stamped “Learning” center).
⭐⭐⭐⭐
Extensive self-serve resources: documentation, webinars, case studies, ROI calculators, and a community forum.
Extensive self-serve resources: documentation, webinars, case studies, ROI calculators, and a community forum.
🏆
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Dedicated one-on-one training via success manager, plus a knowledge base and marketing strategy blog.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Dedicated one-on-one training via success manager, plus a knowledge base and marketing strategy blog.
Pricing
💲
Transparent tiers including a Free plan; affordable for small businesses, but costs rise with volume.
Transparent tiers including a Free plan; affordable for small businesses, but costs rise with volume.
💲💲
Modular pricing per product (Reviews, Loyalty, SMS, etc.) with some free tiers; can become pricey at scale.
Modular pricing per product (Reviews, Loyalty, SMS, etc.) with some free tiers; can become pricey at scale.
💲💲
All-in-one pricing based on customer profiles (starts ~$1,990/mo for up to 80k profiles) with unlimited use of all features.
All-in-one pricing based on customer profiles (starts ~$1,990/mo for up to 80k profiles) with unlimited use of all features.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Omnichannel Flows
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Yotpo’s suite integrates UGC, email, and SMS, while Stamped.io offers only basic review/loyalty automations. Maestra’s unified platform provides true omnichannel marketing automation with advanced personalization.
Stamped.io—Limited. Stamped.io can trigger a few automated emails (like review requests or loyalty point reminders), but it lacks a full omnichannel workflow builder. There’s no built-in integration across channels—for example, it won’t automatically coordinate an email, then an SMS, then a site pop-up as part of one campaign. Any cross-channel flows would rely on external integrations (e.g. using Klaviyo for email or SMSBump for texts).
In short, Stamped helps with loyalty and review prompts, but doesn’t unify multiple channels into a single customer journey.
Yotpo—Moderate. Yotpo includes more channels (notably email and SMS marketing modules along with its reviews and loyalty products), which means you can run multi-channel campaigns to some extent. For example, Yotpo allows an email campaign followed by an SMS reminder for a sale. However, these channels aren’t as tightly unified as Maestra’s.
Creating a flow in Yotpo
There’s no central brain making real-time decisions across channels, so keeping messaging consistent requires more manual effort or additional tools. It’s a step up from Stamped.io, but still not a true “omnichannel flow” builder—rather, it’s separate apps under one umbrella.
Maestra—Advanced. Maestra was built for omnichannel hyper-personalized flows from the ground up. You don’t manage your loyalty program, emails, texts, push notifications, etc. as separate campaigns—instead, you create seamless workflows that span all your channels. For example, a single flow can send an email, then an SMS, then a site pop-up depending on customer behavior, ensuring every touchpoint coordinates to tell the same story.
Because Maestra’s flows are powered by its real-time CDP, they respond to customer actions instantly (if a customer clicks an email but ignores the next step, Maestra can pivot to a different channel automatically). The platform can handle dozens of concurrent automations without performance issues, so you can scale up sophisticated journeys (some Maestra users run more than 50 automated flows).
Maestra’s omnichannel flow builder. Maestra’s visual Flow Builder allows you to design campaigns that move fluidly between email, SMS, push, on-site popups, and ads based on real-time customer behavior
Omnichannel Flows—Winner: Maestra
Overall, Maestra offers the most powerful omnichannel capabilities. Maestra excels here by unifying email, SMS, push, ads, and more into a single, automated flow, letting brands create seamless customer journeys. Yotpo provides basic multi-channel marketing, and Stamped.io is limited to its niche. If you need truly integrated flows, Maestra is the clear winner.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Customer Data Management & Segmentation
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Stamped.io and Yotpo allow you to view and manage only basic customer data. Maestra, by contrast, includes a built-in Customer Data Platform (CDP) and rich segmentation capabilities.
Customer Data Platform (CDP): A CDP is a centralized database for all your customer data (online and offline) that acts as a single source of truth. It’s crucial for personalized marketing at scale. Neither Stamped.io nor Yotpo has a native CDP:
- Stamped.io: Minimal Data Unification. Stamped provides a customer list with basic info like purchase history related to its reviews and loyalty features, but it does not unify data from other channels. There’s no unified customer profile beyond loyalty points or review submissions. All other marketing data (email engagement, site visits, etc.) would live outside Stamped. This means personalization is limited—you can’t easily target someone based on cross-channel behavior because Stamped isn’t collecting that data into one place.
- Yotpo: Basic Profiles, No Unified CDP. Yotpo’s different products each store some customer data (for example, loyalty program status, review history, SMS engagement), and it offers a Segments Plus tool for grouping customers by behavior within those products. However, Yotpo lacks an overarching CDP that ties all data together. In fact, Yotpo often recommends integrating a separate CDP (like their add-on called “Fueled”) for advanced needs. Out-of-the-box, you can see siloed data (e.g., who are your loyalty VIPs, or who left a 5-star review), but you won’t have one unified customer profile that combines all interactions.
- Maestra: Built-in Real-Time CDP. Maestra began as a CDP, so unsurprisingly it delivers a robust, real-time CDP that aggregates data from your website, mobile app, emails, SMS, ads, in-store POS, and more. Every customer has a 360° profile updated in real time—e.g., you can see that Jane Doe viewed Product X on your site, has 1200 loyalty points, and last purchased 3 weeks ago. This unified data powers everything in Maestra (segmentation, triggers, personalization). The benefit: no more disjointed campaigns or conflicting messages, since all channels pull from the same live data.
Segmentation: With or without a CDP, how effectively can you segment your audience?
- Stamped.io: Segmentation is rudimentary—mostly based on loyalty program data. You can group customers by points balance, VIP tier, referral status, etc., to target loyalty emails (for example, remind those with unused points to redeem them). This is useful, but it’s a narrow slice of segmentation (only loyalty-related criteria). There’s no dynamic segmentation by browsing behavior or purchase patterns unless you integrate Stamped with an email platform that has those features. In short, Stamped’s segmentation is loyalty-centric and basic.
- Yotpo: Yotpo’s Segments feature is a bit more advanced. It lets you create segments based on customer behavior and feedback—for instance, customers with high loyalty points but low redemption, or VIP customers who left negative reviews. By combining purchase data with review sentiment, Yotpo helps identify specific groups (like unhappy VIPs who might churn without intervention). Still, these segments are largely confined to data Yotpo itself handles (loyalty and review data). If you want to include, say, email click activity or website browsing behavior in segments, you’d need an external tool. Yotpo’s segmentation is helpful but not comprehensive
Yotpo’s customer page highlighting customizable data
- Maestra: Maestra offers real-time, scheduled, and static segments using ANY data in its CDP. This means you can segment by traditional RFM (Recency, Frequency, Monetary value) scoring, by product interests (e.g. “browsed Category X at least 3 times and hasn’t bought yet”), by engagement (opened 5+ emails last month), by predictive metrics (likelihood to churn or high LTV), and more—often in combination. The segmentation engine allows nested conditions and even computed fields (like auto-tagging a profile with their most viewed product) for extremely granular targeting. Segments update in real time as customers behave, so if someone moves from “idle” to “active” segment, they can immediately enter a new campaign flow. This level of precision ensures campaigns feel personal and timely.
Maestra’s CDP segmentation
Customer Data Management & Segmentation—Winner: Maestra
While Stamped.io and Yotpo rely on basic segmentation from reviews or loyalty data, Maestra’s real-time CDP drives highly granular audience building. This ensures precise, data-driven targeting across all campaigns.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Site Personalization
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐
⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Personalizing the onsite experience—content, product showcases, offers—can significantly boost engagement. Here the gap between Maestra and the others is wide.
Stamped.io: No built-in site personalization features. Stamped.io’s contributions to your site are primarily widgets—e.g. a reviews carousel or star ratings on product pages. While this is valuable social proof, Stamped doesn’t alter site content based on who the visitor is. Such personalization would require another tool (or custom coding).
Creating carousel with customers review in Stamped.io
Yotpo: Yotpo also does not offer native website personalization beyond displaying UGC elements (like a shoppable Instagram gallery or customer photos) and lead forms to collect SMS or email subscribers. It doesn’t have a feature to change site banners, pop-ups, or product sorting based on individual user data. You might leverage Yotpo’s data in other tools—for instance, use loyalty status to personalize content via a third-party personalization engine—but Yotpo itself doesn’t do on-site content personalization.
Yotpo’s lead form settings
Maestra: Maestra includes real-time site personalization out-of-the-box. Because the platform knows who a visitor is (thanks to its CDP and identity resolution), it can personalize content as soon as the page loads. Examples: returning customers might see a “Welcome back, [Name]—you have 200 points!” banner; product recommendations on the homepage will differ for each user based on their browsing/purchase history; first-time visitors might see a different offer than repeat buyers.
Maestra’s pop-up creation page
This all happens through Maestra’s web SDK which can swap out text, images, and even entire sections of the site dynamically for each segment. The result is a tailored shopping experience: each visitor sees the content and promotions most relevant to them, which can greatly increase conversion rates.
Site Personalization—Winner: Maestra
Maestra’s ability to adapt on-site content in real time based on customer data is a unique strength that helps brands deliver an Amazon-like personalized experience on their own site.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Email Marketing
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Stamped.io enables basic email capabilities tied to reviews and loyalty, Yotpo offers a more complete email marketing tool (especially for Shopify users), and Maestra provides an advanced proprietary email platform.
Stamped.io: Stamped.io is not an email marketing platform per se, but it does send out certain emails: for example, review request emails (after a purchase, asking the customer to leave a review) and loyalty program emails (points balance updates, reward available notifications, referral invites, etc.). You can configure these transactional emails and maybe do light customization.
Stamped.io allows to send review request email
However, Stamped.io doesn’t have a full campaign builder for newsletters or promotional blasts. For broader email campaigns, you’d integrate a dedicated email service (like Klaviyo, Mailchimp, etc.)—Stamped can pass data (like who has how many points) to those services via integration.
In summary, Stamped covers the UGC-basics (reviews and rewards emails) but relies on other tools for rich email marketing.
Yotpo: Yotpo offers a relatively robust email marketing module (especially oriented toward Shopify stores). It includes a drag-and-drop email builder and templates, plus some AI-based product recommendations to include in emails. Common flows like welcome series, abandoned cart emails, and win-back campaigns are available as pre-built automation.
Yotpo’s email templates
Yotpo’s email also supports features like domain authentication for better deliverability and even an email warm-up tool to gradually increase send volume. For analytics, you get open/click rates and basic performance dashboards. The main limitation is personalization—since Yotpo lacks deep data unification, emails are mostly one-size-fits-all or segmented by simple criteria.
Still, for many e-commerce SMBs (especially on Shopify), Yotpo’s email tool can replace an ESP, covering their needs for promotional campaigns and some automation.
Maestra: Maestra includes a full-fledged, proprietary email marketing platform. It has a drag-and-drop Email Composer that generates clean, lightweight HTML (to prevent Gmail clipping and spam issues). The level of control is very granular: you can design dynamic email content blocks that show different content to different segments in the same email send. For example, one email campaign can have a banner that varies by customer segment (new vs. loyal vs. lapsed)—all managed within one email design.
Maestra’s built-in email editor allows dynamic content insertion (e.g., personalized product grids, loyalty point balances) directly from your customer data
Because Maestra’s email ties into its CDP, you can personalize any element: product recommendations, the text (“Hi John” vs “Hi Jane”), even images or language can change based on the recipient’s data. Maestra also supports advanced features like AMP for Email (interactive email content), automatic UTM tracking, A/B testing subject lines and content, and email health monitoring to track deliverability and inbox placement. Essentially, Maestra’s email tool is on par with top standalone ESPs—but with the advantage of native integration with all your other channels and data.
Email Marketing—Winner: Maestra
In terms of email marketing power, Maestra leads, especially for personalization-heavy campaigns. Yotpo is a solid middle-ground with a user-friendly email tool for standard campaigns, and Stamped.io covers only operational emails for reviews/loyalty unless you add another platform.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: SMS Marketing
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
SMS is increasingly important for reaching customers. Stamped.io doesn’t include SMS natively, Yotpo has a dedicated SMS marketing product, and Maestra treats SMS as an integral channel in its omnichannel toolkit.
Stamped.io: Stamped.io has no built-in SMS campaign feature. It cannot, for example, send a text message to customers about a promotion or an abandoned cart on its own. The only SMS-related capability might be sending review requests via SMS (if integrated with an SMS service) or alerting a referral via text, but those would require hooking Stamped into another tool.
In practice, if an e-commerce merchant using Stamped wants to do SMS marketing, they’d likely use a separate platform (like Klaviyo SMS, Attentive, or SMSBump) and integrate it. Stamped might pass along loyalty data to that SMS platform (e.g. to include point balances in a text), but it’s not an SMS sender itself.
Yotpo: Yotpo acquired SMSBump, so it offers a native SMS Marketing solution as part of its suite. This means you can collect SMS subscribers (often via pop-ups or at checkout) and send them text campaigns directly from Yotpo.
Yotpo SMS builder
Yotpo’s SMS can be automated for things like abandoned cart reminders, VIP offers, birthday texts, review requests via SMS, etc. It also supports compliance (opt-in management) and can integrate with Yotpo Loyalty (for instance, you can reward customers with loyalty points for opting into SMS, or send points balance updates via text).
Compared to Maestra, Yotpo’s SMS lacks some of the cross-channel finesse—it’s mostly used in parallel with email campaigns (and indeed, Yotpo’s interface tries to unify email and SMS in one place). But for practical purposes, Yotpo gives you a strong SMS marketing capability: you can run targeted text campaigns, two-way messaging (if a customer replies STOP, it handles that), and track SMS-specific metrics.
Maestra: In Maestra, SMS is treated as a first-class channel, just like email. You can create bulk SMS campaigns or one-off automated texts within the omnichannel Flow Builder.
Maestra’s SMS stands out for a few reasons: it can do cross-device tracking (recognizing if a customer clicks an SMS link on mobile vs desktop and tying that to their profile), it automatically uses short links for tracking clicks (to save character count), and it supports personalization in SMS content (e.g., “Hi John, your order is on the way…” or recommending a product in a text).
Maestra SMS builder
Нou can also A/B test SMS messages in Maestra and include them in multi-step workflows (e.g., send an SMS only if the person didn’t open an email). Since Maestra’s SMS is fully integrated, you avoid the common issue of customers getting redundant or conflicting messages from separate systems. For example, Maestra ensures if a customer already redeemed an offer from an email, they won’t get an SMS about that same offer. Additionally, Maestra’s SMS is built for scale (it advertises sending up to 250k texts/hour). Essentially, Maestra provides enterprise-grade SMS marketing as part of the package.
SMS Marketing—Winner: Maestra
Stamped.io lacks native SMS. Yotpo’s SMS module is robust, but still siloed from other channels. Maestra treats SMS as a first-class citizen in its unified marketing platform, powering highly personalized texting at scale.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Loyalty Programs
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Loyalty features are a core offering of Stamped.io and Yotpo, whereas Maestra offers loyalty as part of a larger integrated approach. All three support points, tiers, and rewards—but Maestra extends loyalty with more personalization.
Stamped.io: This is one of Stamped’s main strengths. It provides a full points-based loyalty program module, a VIP tier system, and referral rewards. You can define how customers earn points (purchases, social follows, birthdays, etc.), and what rewards they can redeem (discounts, free products, gift cards, etc.).
It’s quite customizable—for instance, you can set point expiration, rename points (“Coins”, “Gems”, whatever fits your brand), and design VIP tiers (Silver, Gold, etc.) with different perks. Essentially, Stamped.io focuses on “turning first-time customers into loyal repeat customers” through gamification and rewards.
Loyalty program rules in Stamped.io
One limitation: Stamped’s loyalty actions are mostly transactional (buy, earn points; refer, earn points). It doesn’t inherently connect loyalty with other channels—e.g., it won’t automatically send an email when someone reaches a new tier unless you integrate an email tool. But as a standalone loyalty program, it’s feature-rich and effective for SMBs.
Yotpo: With Yotpo Loyalty & Referrals, you can create a program with points for purchases and other actions, set up VIP tiers, offer rewards like coupons or free products, and run referral incentives. Yotpo also has a nice loyalty UI widget you can add to your site (as does Stamped) so customers can log in to see their points and rewards.
Yotpo’s referral program settings
One advantage Yotpo touts is some pre-made campaign options—for example, a referral campaign template or a “double points for the holidays” promotion—so you don’t have to start from scratch. The difference from Stamped is not huge here; it’s more about Yotpo’s loyalty being one piece of a larger suite. Both are top-notch loyalty solutions for rewarding customers.
One thing to note: neither Stamped nor Yotpo inherently tie loyalty into personalization beyond the loyalty program itself. They don’t automatically, say, feature a VIP-exclusive product recommendation on the homepage (unless you custom build it). They mainly handle the program logic and customer-facing components like points balances and reward redemption.
Maestra: Maestra approaches loyalty a bit differently. It offers points, tiers, referrals just like the others, but because it has all that customer data and other channels, it can do more with it. For example, Maestra allows targeted promotions to specific segments within your loyalty program—you could give one segment of customers 2x points on a certain product category this week, and a different segment might see a different offer.
Sample loyalty program showing Maestra’s flexible customization
Also, Maestra’s loyalty is deeply connected to other channels: you can automatically email a customer when they hit a new VIP tier with a special offer, or show a pop-up with an upsell that offers bonus points if they add a certain item. It also supports “stackable” promotions (like combining a discount with bonus points on the same purchase) which the standalone loyalty tools typically don’t handle. In essence, Maestra’s loyalty program is part of a larger personalized marketing strategy rather than a standalone gamification layer.
Loyalty Programs—Winner: Maestra
Both Stamped.io and Yotpo offer strong, standalone loyalty and referral tools, but Maestra’s built-in loyalty ties seamlessly into its CDP, enabling more personalized, data-driven rewards and incentives across channels.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Promotions & Referrals
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
All three platforms support referral marketing and promotions to some extent, but the depth varies. Stamped.io and Yotpo both let you run points-based referral programs and basic promotions, while Maestra offers more flexible promotional rules.
Stamped.io: Stamped includes a referral program feature as part of its loyalty suite (much like Smile.io or other loyalty apps). You can set up a referral offer—for example, “Give your friend 10% off, and get 100 points when they make a purchase.” Stamped will generate referral links/codes for your customers and track the referrals.
Stamped’s referral program settings
It also has basic promotion capabilities tied to points (customers can redeem points for coupons, etc.). However, Stamped’s promotions are generally loyalty-driven. You’re not going to set up arbitrary one-off promotions (like “flash sale for category X shoppers”) within Stamped—those would be handled in your e-commerce platform or another marketing tool.
So, referrals: yes; flexible promotions: limited. The referral program in Stamped is solid for word-of-mouth growth, and loyalty points can be considered a promotion currency, but you won’t get the advanced promo targeting that Maestra offers.
Yotpo: Yotpo’s Loyalty & Referrals product mirrors many of Stamped’s features. You can run referral campaigns (with configurable rewards for both referrer and referee) and loyalty promotions like points for certain actions.
Yotpo stands out by offering some pre-built campaign templates—for instance, a referral campaign template or a “double points for the holidays” promotion—so you don’t have to start from scratch. This is helpful for marketers who want quick wins.
Yotpo’s rewards page builder
Still, Yotpo’s promotions are within the bounds of its loyalty program (points, tiers, discounts). It doesn’t natively create, say, personalized coupon codes for segmented campaigns (you’d integrate with your email for that).
In short, Yotpo covers referrals well (similar to Stamped) and offers basic loyalty promotions (points offers, tier perks). It’s great for standard points = rewards style engagement, but not intended for complex promotional strategies.
Maestra: Maestra treats promotions as a broad concept that goes beyond traditional loyalty points. You can do points, tier rewards, and referrals (just like the other two), but Maestra also allows general promotion rules: e.g., “Customers in segment X get 15% off on their next purchase, ” or “Flash sale: everyone who bought in the last month gets free shipping this weekend.” These can be triggered by behaviors or attributes (time, location, product affinity, etc.).
Maestra’s promotions builder
A unique feature is the ability to combine or sequence promotions. For instance, you could run a promo that gives “10% off + 50 bonus points” together for a certain event, or automatically follow up a lapsed-customer coupon with a points offer if the coupon wasn’t used.
Referrals in Maestra can be part of these flows too—because Maestra has your referral data, you could, say, target customers who referred 3+ friends with a special gift (something not possible to automate easily in other tools). Maestra basically merges traditional loyalty/referral programs with a general promotion engine that’s very flexible and data-driven.
Promotions & Referrals—Winner: Maestra
Bottom line: If your needs are straightforward—points programs and refer-a-friend campaigns—Stamped.io and Yotpo both have you covered. They each make it easy to reward referrals and run loyalty promotions. Maestra is the choice if you want to go further, crafting promotions based on more complex criteria or combining multiple incentives for maximum impact.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Website & Email Product Recommendations
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐
⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Both Stamped.io and Yotpo don’t have a native system for product recommendations. Maestra, on the other hand, includes a powerful recommendation engine.
Stamped.io: Stamped’s strength is social proof, not cross-selling or upselling. But you can add product recommendations to review request email.
Stamped.io: adding product recommendations in review request email
Yotpo: Yotpo similarly does not provide native product recommendations. While Yotpo’s suite is robust for UGC, loyalty, and email/SMS, it has no built-in AI or logic to dynamically recommend products.
Maestra: Maestra includes a sophisticated recommendation engine that analyzes user behavior (browsing, purchase history, product affinity) in real time. Its machine learning system uses 14 different algorithms (like collaborative filtering, bestsellers, recent views, etc.) and chooses which recommendation strategy to use for each user based on context.
Maestra’s personal recommendation
It can dynamically populate recommendation widgets on your site (e.g., product pages, homepage, cart pages) and in your marketing emails. For example, you might send a back-in-stock email with automatically pulled product suggestions relevant to that individual’s interests. Because it’s tied to Maestra’s CDP, the recommendations are always up to date and can be personalized for each user.
Product Recommendations—Winner: Maestra
Stamped.io and Yotpo offer no built-in recommendation engines, so you’d need a third-party app to serve dynamic product suggestions. Maestra, on the other hand, integrates AI-driven recommendations right into its platform—both on-site and in emails—creating highly personalized suggestions based on each shopper’s real-time browsing and purchase behavior.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Mobile & Web Push Notifications
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐
⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Neither Stamped.io nor Yotpo include push notification capabilities by default, whereas Maestra does.
Stamped.io: No native support for mobile app pushes or web push notifications. In theory, you could integrate a push service and maybe use Stamped’s data (like send a push when someone earns points), but that would all be custom work.
Yotpo: Similarly, Yotpo does not provide a web push or mobile push notification feature. Yotpo’s focus is email/SMS/UGC; push is outside its scope.
Both Stamped and Yotpo might allow some workaround (for instance, using Zapier or custom code to trigger a push when something happens in loyalty), but that’s not the same as having a built-in feature.
Maestra: Maestra includes web push and mobile push notifications as part of its omnichannel approach. You can prompt website visitors to allow browser notifications and then send them targeted pushes (for example, “Price drop on an item in your wishlist!”). If you have a mobile app, Maestra can integrate with it to send app push notifications as well.
Maestra’s SMS builder
The push notifications are fully customizable—you can include images, tailor the copy, and deep-link to specific pages. And importantly, Maestra’s push can be tied into the same flows as email/SMS. So, for example, an abandoned cart flow might send an email first, then a push notification an hour later if the user subscribed to push.
With performance tracking, Maestra lets you see how pushes contribute (click-throughs, conversions) and optimize accordingly. It also has frequency capping and scheduling to ensure pushes are sent at optimal times without spamming the user.
Mobile and Web Push Notifications—Winner: Maestra
Maestra is the only one of the three with push notification capabilities built-in. This can be a significant channel (particularly web push for capturing anonymous visitors or mobile push for app users). If push marketing is on your roadmap, Maestra provides it out of the box, whereas with Stamped or Yotpo you’ll be adding another tool to your stack.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: User-Generated Content (UGC)
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐
Yotpo is known for its UGC and reviews prowess. Stamped.io is also focused on reviews (a form of UGC), while Maestra doesn’t collect UGC but can leverage it via incentives.
Stamped.io: Stamped.io began as a product reviews platform, so UGC collection and display is a core competency. Through Stamped.io, you can automatically email customers post-purchase to collect reviews (star ratings and text feedback, with photos or videos). Those reviews can be showcased on your site (product pages, a gallery page, etc.).
Stamped.io: enabling the photo/video upload feature
Stamped also has features like Q&A (allowing prospective customers to ask questions and get answers, which becomes part of the UGC on product pages). So in terms of UGC, Stamped helps gather and amplify customer feedback and content. It’s slightly less expansive than Yotpo’s UGC suite—for example, Yotpo has a specific Instagram curation tool, whereas Stamped’s equivalent might not be as advanced. But many merchants find Stamped’s review management to be excellent and sufficient.
Bottom line: with Stamped, you’ll get plenty of UGC (reviews, ratings, customer photos in reviews) to use as social proof, but you might need to manually reuse that content in ads or social media since Stamped doesn’t have deep social integration.
Yotpo: Yotpo shines here. It’s a leader in UGC for e-commerce. Yotpo not only collects product reviews and ratings like Stamped, but also integrates with social media to pull in content. For instance, Yotpo can help you collect Instagram posts from customers (with permissions) and turn them into a shoppable gallery on your site.
Yotpo: filtering visual UGC
It uses AI to tag and filter UGC (like identifying which photos contain your product). Yotpo’s review management is robust: you have a dashboard to moderate reviews (approve, respond, ask reviewers for more info, etc.). They also let you solicit reviews via SMS in addition to email. Essentially, Yotpo doesn’t just treat reviews as text on a page—it helps you repurpose UGC in marketing, from showcasing five-star reviews in Facebook ads to embedding customer photos in emails.
If UGC (in all forms: text, photo, video) is a big part of your strategy, Yotpo offers the most features to support that.
Maestra: Maestra does not have a built-in review or UGC collection tool.
What Maestra does do is allow you to incentivize UGC. For example, using Maestra’s loyalty/promotions, you can reward customers with points or coupons for submitting a review or sharing a photo on social media. Maestra can also run post-purchase surveys or feedback forms (not public reviews, but to gauge satisfaction). Any UGC you collect, you could import into Maestra’s CDP as data (for example, tag customers who gave a 5-star review and then target them with referral asks).
Maestra helps Decathlon collect customer feedback via emails
But Maestra won’t host a reviews widget on your site—you’d still use another app for that and possibly sync the data to Maestra.
User-Generated Content (UGC)—Winner: Yotpo
Yotpo shines for capturing, moderating, and showcasing reviews, photos, and user-created galleries. Stamped.io is close behind with review-focused UGC, while Maestra focuses more on leveraging existing UGC data rather than collecting it.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Ad Optimization
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐
⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Stamped.io doesn’t directly touch ads, Yotpo assists by injecting UGC into ads, and Maestra optimizes ads via audience segmentation.
Stamped.io: There are no direct ad integration or optimization features in Stamped.
The indirect way Stamped can help with ads is by supplying content: your customer reviews and ratings gathered via Stamped can be used as social proof in your ads. But doing so is manual—you’d export or copy that content into your ad platforms.
Still, when it comes to actively managing or optimizing ad campaigns, Stamped has no tools for that.
Yotpo: Yotpo takes a UGC-driven approach to ad optimization. It integrates with platforms like Facebook Ads and Google Ads in a few ways. One, Yotpo can automatically push star ratings to Google so that your Google Shopping listings show star ratings (Google Seller Ratings integration). Two, Yotpo’s integration with Facebook lets you create Dynamic Product Ads that include customer reviews—for instance, a carousel ad on Facebook that not only shows the product image, but also a snippet of a 5-star review underneath it. These kinds of ads leveraging UGC tend to perform better because they add trust.
Yotpo: web dynamic ads creation
Yotpo also can sync basic segments (like loyalty VIPs) to Facebook as custom audiences, although complex audience building might need another tool. Additionally, Yotpo has partnered with ad optimization services (like AdRoll and AdScale) to use review content in ads automatically. So, while Yotpo isn’t an “ad platform, ” it augments your ads with social proof and helps you retarget users using the customer data it has. This can lead to better ROI on ad spend.
Maestra: Maestra approaches ad optimization through the lens of audience and data. You can create custom audiences for ad platforms based on Maestra’s segmentation (e.g., sync a list of high-value customers to Facebook for a lookalike audience, or send a segment of “cart abandoners in last 7 days” to Google for retargeting). Because these audiences update in real time from Maestra’s CDP, your ad targeting is always using the latest data (no more manually uploading CSVs of emails to Facebook!).
Maestra: ad optimization settings
Maestra ensures that your ad dollars are spent on the right people: it can exclude customers who just purchased from seeing prospecting ads (saving money), and include those who are most likely to buy. Over time, this precision can reduce cost-per-acquisition and improve ROAS.
Also, Maestra leverages things like lead ads—if you run a Facebook Lead Ad campaign (to collect emails/SMS), those leads flow into Maestra instantly and can trigger follow-ups. While Maestra doesn’t generate ad creative, it plays the role of orchestrating who should see what ad by syncing with Google, Facebook, Instagram, etc.
Ad Optimization—Winner: Maestra
Yotpo helps make your ads more convincing (with UGC), and Maestra helps make your ads more efficient (with better targeting and automation). Stamped.io doesn’t contribute much directly to ads aside from giving you content to manually use.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Reporting and Attribution
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Analytics capabilities differ in breadth: Stamped.io focuses on loyalty and review metrics, Yotpo provides dashboards per product (reviews, loyalty, etc.), and Maestra offers comprehensive reporting tying everything together.
Stamped.io: Stamped’s reporting is centered on the features it provides—primarily reviews and loyalty. For reviews, you’ll see stats like total reviews collected, average rating, and maybe sentiment over time. For loyalty, Stamped offers reports such as points issued vs. redeemed, top customers (points leaders), referral conversions, and the impact of the loyalty program on sales (e.g., how much revenue involves redeemed rewards). You can export data to CSV for deeper analysis if needed.
Stamped’s revenue dashboard
If NPS surveys are used (Stamped has an NPS feature on higher plans), you’d see NPS scores and trends. However, Stamped does not have marketing attribution analytics (it won’t tell you if a campaign increased sales, beyond loyalty redemption tracking). It’s fairly siloed: you get insights like “our loyalty program ROI is X”, but you won’t get insight into overall revenue from email vs SMS, etc., since Stamped isn’t handling those channels.
Yotpo: Yotpo provides separate analytics dashboards for each of its products. For example:
- Loyalty Dashboard: shows enrollment, points issued, points redeemed, redemption rate, repeat purchase rate of loyalty members vs non-members, etc. It helps prove the loyalty program’s value (ROI, incremental sales from loyalty).
- Reviews Dashboard: shows review volume over time, average ratings, a breakdown by rating, maybe a word cloud or sentiment analysis of review content, and sources of reviews (how many via email request vs other sources).
- SMS Dashboard: (if using Yotpo SMS) would show SMS revenue, click-through rates, subscriber growth.
- Email Dashboard: shows email campaign performance (opens, clicks, conversion, revenue per email).
Yotpo also has an Insights section where it aggregates customer feedback (reviews Q&A) to highlight common themes and do some competitive benchmarking.
Оverall, Yotpo gives a rich set of metrics within each domain (it’s much more analytical than Stamped.io in reviews and loyalty)
Yotpo’s conversion dashboards
Maestra: Maestra offers a suite of analytics dashboards that cover everything from high-level business KPIs down to campaign-specific metrics. Examples:
- Goals & Revenue Attribution: You can set business goals (like “increase repeat purchase rate to X%”) and Maestra tracks progress, attributing which campaigns and channels drive those goals.
- Loyalty Program Dashboard: comprehensive view of loyalty performance.
- Campaign Performance: an overview of all campaigns across channels, showing impressions, clicks, conversions, and revenue per campaign—whether it was an email, SMS, push, or multi-channel flow.
- Deliverability & Health: email health monitoring, which benchmarks your open rates, spam rates, etc., against industry standards.
- A/B Testing Reports: if you run experiments (emails, subject lines, different offer test groups), Maestra provides results with statistical significance. Maestra can show that a particular flow generated $X extra revenue compared to if those customers had received nothing (using holdout groups).
Also, data export is completely open—you can query or export any data anytime. In short, Maestra gives you end-to-end visibility: you can see how each channel and campaign contributes to sales, and how they interact (attribution). This is something neither Stamped nor Yotpo can do fully, since they handle only parts of the puzzle.
Maestra’s custom goals dashboard
Maestra’s loyalty program dashboard
Reporting and Attribution—Winner: Maestra
Stamped.io and Yotpo provide detailed dashboards for loyalty, reviews, or SMS, but lack unified analytics. Maestra’s all-in-one attribution pinpoints which channels and campaigns drive the most revenue, giving brands holistic insight.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Customer Support
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
All three companies offer customer support, but the level of hands-on service differs. Maestra provides a dedicated success manager to all clients, whereas Stamped.io and Yotpo offer more standard support (with premium tiers for higher-paying customers).
Stamped.io: Stamped.io is often praised for its support team’s responsiveness. Many users (especially on Shopify) have noted that Stamped’s support will go above and beyond to help with setup or troubleshooting. On standard plans, you get the typical support; on higher plans, you might get faster response SLAs or an onboarding specialist.
Stamped, as a smaller company perhaps, places a big emphasis on customer success even if you’re not enterprise.
Yotpo: Yotpo provides multi-channel support (email, chat) and has a comprehensive help center. However, the level of personalized support you get depends on your plan. For small customers on lower-cost plans or using only a free tier of one product, support might be more self-service (help center, community) plus standard ticketing.
On higher paid plans, Yotpo offers an “Dedicated Optimization Strategist” or Account Manager for premium and enterprise clients. This is someone who can advise on using Yotpo’s features best, somewhat like a CSM.
The general sentiment in the market is that Yotpo’s support is adequate but can be slow unless you’re a big account. They do handle migrations (for example, migrating reviews from another platform) for new customers which is helpful. So Yotpo’s support is good but not exceptional—and many smaller brands might not get white-glove treatment unless they pay for higher tiers.
Maestra: Maestra’s approach to support is a major differentiator. Every Maestra client, regardless of size or pricing tier, gets a dedicated Customer Success Manager (CSM) from day one. This person is essentially an extension of your marketing team. They will help plan your strategy, set up your campaigns and flows, assist with technical integration, and continue to meet with you (weekly or bi-weekly) to review performance and suggest optimizations. It’s truly white-glove service.
On top of that, Maestra boasts extremely fast general support (under 5 minute response on live chat for any user). The CSM will proactively monitor your account, help with deliverability, and ensure you’re using features to the fullest.
This level of hand-holding is usually only seen in enterprise software with very high fees; Maestra includes it for all customers. The benefit is you’re never alone in executing your marketing—if your team is small or not expert in, say, email deliverability, Maestra’s team steps in to help.
Customer Support—Winner: Maestra
Stamped.io is known for its friendly support; Yotpo’s help is solid but tier-based. Maestra stands out by assigning a dedicated success manager to all clients, providing hands-on assistance from setup to strategy.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Integration Capabilities
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Integration with the rest of your tech stack is important to consider. Stamped.io and Yotpo both integrate with numerous e-commerce apps, while Maestra offers custom integration support in addition to ready-made connectors.
Stamped.io: Stamped.io was built with e-commerce platform integrations in mind. It has native apps/integrations for Shopify, BigCommerce, Magento, WooCommerce, etc. (making installation and data syncing straightforward on those platforms). It also integrates with popular marketing tools—for example, it has a Klaviyo integration (to sync review data for emails), and connects with Google Shopping for pushing review stars. Stamped provides APIs and webhooks for developers to create custom connections if needed.
Overall, it has integrations for typical needs: email service providers, some CRMs, etc. For anything beyond that, one could use Zapier or the API. Stamped’s own site mentions “Experience the benefits of Stamped’s Reviews and Loyalty on a single unified platform, ” which refers more to integrating its own products together. But externally, Stamped aims to fit into your stack without excessive hassle. For instance, integration directories show they connect with things like Google Analytics and Facebook (for sharing reviews), and loyalty integrations for POS systems.
Yotpo: Yotpo boasts over 170 integrations. This includes direct integrations with e-commerce platforms, email providers (if you weren’t using Yotpo Email), helpdesks like Gorgias and Zendesk (so customer support can see loyalty status or review history), analytics dashboards, Facebook/Google ad platforms, and more.
Yotpo’s strategy is to either build or partner for as many integrations as possible—they know merchants use lots of apps. For example, Yotpo integrates with Google for Seller Ratings and with platforms like Shopify Flow for automating tasks. If you have a specific app in your stack, chances are Yotpo either has an out-of-the-box integration or documented way to connect. They also have APIs for all their products if custom integration is needed.
The main point: Yotpo is very integration-friendly, reflecting its role as an add-on suite that needs to play nice in the Shopify ecosystem especially.
Maestra: Maestra provides ready-to-use integrations for common systems (particularly your e-commerce platform, SMS carriers, ad platforms).
But if an integration you need isn’t already available, Maestra will build it as part of their service. With a robust API and webhooks, Maestra can connect to basically anything: your warehouse software, your ERP, a custom data source, etc. And rather than leaving you to figure it out, your dedicated success manager and Maestra’s engineering team will assist in crafting those integrations. This is a big deal for larger brands who might have custom back-end systems—Maestra ensures data can flow in and out freely.
Additionally, Maestra’s integration monitoring will alert if any data pipeline breaks, ensuring reliability. In effect, Maestra can become your central hub, and they are willing to do custom integration work to achieve that.
Integration Capabilities—Tied: Maestra & Yotpo
Stamped.io integrates well with major e-commerce platforms, but Yotpo edges it out with 170 integrations. Maestra similarly offers an extensive connector library plus custom integration development if needed.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Educational Resources
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
Beyond support, what resources are available for learning and maximizing each platform?
Stamped.io: Stamped offers a help center/knowledge base (with guides on setup, FAQs, and troubleshooting). They also have a blog (it provides e-commerce marketing tips, feature updates, etc.). Because Stamped is popular in the Shopify community, you’ll also find community forum discussions and third-party blogs covering how to use Stamped.
In short, Stamped’s educational content is solid but not extraordinary—typical of a focused SaaS tool (guides, blog posts, and responsive support to fill in gaps).
Yotpo: Yotpo invests heavily in content and resources. On Yotpo’s site you’ll find a resource center with guides, ebooks, webinars, and case studies on topics like improving customer retention, building loyalty programs, etc. They also have a Yotpo Academy with on-demand videos.
Additionally, Yotpo runs events and has an inspiration gallery showcasing how other brands use UGC. The support site has not just help articles but also best practice articles.
So, merchants have no shortage of learning materials with Yotpo. It’s a matter of dedicating time to consume them.
Maestra: Maestra is newer on the scene, but it provides a different kind of education through its service model.
The dedicated success manager is effectively your tutor/consultant, giving you personalized guidance and strategies. This often surpasses generic articles because they’ll directly teach you using your own data and campaigns as examples (e.g., showing you how to build a particular segment or flow step by step).
Maestra also has a Help Center with how-to articles, and a blog which covers marketing strategies.
Essentially, Maestra’s educational approach is more high-touch and tailored: rather than you seeking out info, your CSM proactively educates your team in regular calls and provides documentation or even custom playbooks for you. For many mid-sized brands, this is actually preferable, as it shortcuts the learning curve.
Educational Resources—Winner: Maestra
All three platforms provide knowledge bases and blogs, but Maestra’s personalized training via a dedicated customer success manager, combined with robust online resources, offers the most comprehensive learning experience.
Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra: Pricing
Stamped.io
Yotpo
Maestra
💲
💲💲
💲💲
Each platform has a different pricing model: Yotpo and Maestra are more comprehensive (and higher cost) solutions, while Stamped.io offers affordable plans including a free tier. Let’s compare the pricing structures and value.
Stamped.io Pricing: Stamped.io is one of the more affordable options for reviews & loyalty. They have tiered plans, including a Free plan for basic use. For example, Stamped’s free tier might allow up to a certain number of review requests per month (say 50) and basic loyalty features for a single store. Then they have paid plans that scale by the volume of orders or review requests:
- Basic plan (~$19/month)—increased review request quota (e.g., 200 per month), some branding customization, maybe basic loyalty.
- Mid-tier plan (~$49/month)—higher quotas (e.g., 500 review requests), adds more features like photo reviews, advanced widgets, integration with Klaviyo, etc.
- Business/Professional (~$119-$249/month)—thousands of review requests, all features unlocked (NPS, Instagram UGC, VIP tiers, etc.).
- Enterprise (custom pricing)—unlimited usage, a dedicated success rep, API access, etc.
Stamped’s pricing is transparent and mostly based on usage (orders or review requests). Importantly, Stamped is generally cheaper than Yotpo for similar functionality—often significantly so. Many reviews cite cost savings as a reason to choose Stamped over Yotpo. However, as you grow, the costs can add up (e.g., the $249/mo plan), and if you need multiple advanced features, you might end up on a higher plan. Still, for what it offers, Stamped delivers great value, especially for small to mid-sized businesses.
Yotpo Pricing: Yotpo’s pricing is more complex because it’s modular. Each product (Reviews, Loyalty, SMS, Email, Subscriptions) can be purchased a la carte, or you can go for a bundled “suite” plan. They do have some free plans—notably, Yotpo Reviews has a free tier (for up to a certain number of orders) and Yotpo Loyalty has a free tier (up to 500 orders/month). The free tiers are limited in features but let small brands start at no cost. As you scale:
- Yotpo Reviews: Paid plans start around $15/mo (for small order counts) and increase with order volume and features (Pro, Premium tiers).
- Yotpo Loyalty: Paid plans might start around $199/mo for the Pro (up to X orders, more reward customization). Enterprise loyalty is custom priced.
- Yotpo SMS & Email: These are usage-based (you pay per message or per number of subscribers/emails sent). For instance, SMS might be ~$0.0072 per SMS, and email might have a base price for certain sending volumes.
- Full Suite: Yotpo often quotes something like $300-$+1000/month for bundles that include multiple products on lower tiers, and enterprise bundles can be thousands per month.
In general, Yotpo is one of the pricier options in this space. It’s positioned as a premium platform and often targets brands that are willing to invest for all-in-one. The cost can escalate quickly if you want to use, say, Loyalty + Reviews + SMS all together—each with high usage. On the flip side, if you only need one thing (e.g., just reviews or just loyalty) and you’re small, you might pay nothing or a low amount. Many growing brands start on Stamped (cheaper) and later face a decision to either pay more for Yotpo’s broader features or stick with piecemeal tools.
Yotpo’s pricing reflects its capabilities: it can replace several tools, but you’ll likely be paying for multiple modules.
Maestra Pricing: Maestra’s pricing is more straightforward but at a higher entry point. They charge based on the number of customer profiles in your database (i.e., the size of your CDP) and unlimited use of all features comes included. Starting around $1,990/month for up to 80,000 customer profiles, Maestra is clearly targeting established businesses rather than very small stores. That price includes everything: all channels (email, SMS, loyalty, etc.), the CDP, and the full white-glove support. As your profile count grows, the price increases in tiers. However, notably:
- Email sending is unlimited at no extra cost (that alone can replace a huge ESP bill).
- SMS is charged at a low rate (around $0.0045 per SMS, which is cheaper than Yotpo’s rate).
Maestra doesn’t have a free plan or a cheap plan—it’s a significant investment, but the value is that you’re consolidating many tools into one. If you compare cost “per feature, ” a mid-market brand might be paying for Klaviyo + a loyalty app + a personalization tool + a CDP + maybe a services retainer—added up, that could rival Maestra’s cost.
As you scale, the cost per profile becomes lower, making it economically better for large databases than paying per email or per message with other tools. And the white-glove service is included, which itself could be worth thousands if you consider hiring marketing consultants.
Pricing—Depends on Stage & Scope
So, for budget-conscious small businesses, Stamped.io is the clear winner with its low-cost plans. For value at scale (and if you want to simplify your stack), Maestra can actually be cost-effective when replacing multiple point solutions (though the entry cost is high). Yotpo sits in between—flexible pricing (you can start low, even free, with one product) but becomes expensive as you add products or grow.
Final Verdict: Stamped.io vs Yotpo vs Maestra
Stamped.io is an excellent starting point for smaller brands that need a cost-effective reviews and loyalty solution. Yotpo is a logical next step when you want to add UGC, reviews, and basic multi-channel marketing—but be mindful of its cost and integration needs as you grow. Maestra is the powerhouse for when your marketing strategy matures and you require a unified, data-driven approach across all channels.
If you’re just launching loyalty and review initiatives and have a limited budget, Stamped.io is the best place to start. It will cover the fundamentals of customer feedback and rewards without breaking the bank. Once you’ve expanded a bit and want to incorporate campaigns around that UGC and loyalty data (like sending emails or texts tied to reviews/points), you might consider graduating to Yotpo. Yotpo will let you leverage those reviews in your marketing and add more channels like SMS, all within one ecosystem.
Both Stamped and Yotpo shine for early-stage and growing e-commerce brands in their initial marketing lifecycle. They’re relatively easy to implement and focus on specific wins (UGC, loyalty) rather than holistic personalization. However, as your business scales, you may hit the ceiling of what they can do. You’ll find yourself needing additional tools—perhaps a separate email platform, a separate CDP, etc., leading to a fragmented stack and higher costs to maintain multiple subscriptions.
That’s where Maestra comes in. When you reach the point where customer data and personalized cross-channel engagement become your main focus—in other words, when you’re serious about crafting an individualized customer journey across email, SMS, website, ads, and more—Maestra is the solution built for that challenge. It consolidates the capabilities of many tools into one, and more importantly, it ensures all your tactics work in harmony powered by real-time data.
Use Stamped.io if:
- You want an affordable reviews and loyalty platform to start building customer retention.
- You don’t need advanced omnichannel features or deep data integration yet.
- You’re a small or early-stage brand that primarily needs to establish social proof (reviews) and a simple rewards program.
Use Yotpo if:
- You need a mix of products (UGC, loyalty, email, SMS) and are okay with separate pricing for each as you assemble what you need.
- You want to leverage customer content (reviews, photos) heavily in your marketing campaigns.
- You’re an SMB that’s scaling and can handle a higher marketing spend for a more comprehensive solution than Stamped, but are not yet ready for an all-in-one like Maestra.
Use Maestra if:
- You want a unified marketing tech stack with a single platform acting as your CDP, email/SMS engine, personalization tool, loyalty program, and more.
- You value having a dedicated customer success manager and essentially an outsourced expert as part of your team to ensure you succeed.
- You’re a growing mid-market brand (or an ambitious SMB) that is investing in scaling your marketing across multiple channels and prioritizes personalization and data-driven decision making to drive ROI.