Unidragon implemented Mindbox with the aim of launching bulk campaigns, behavior- and region-based segmentation, personalized pop-ups on their website, and automated communications without the need for a developer. Within three months, Unidragon’s marketer launched 12 marketing workflows that combined personalized discounts, pop-ups, and automated email campaigns, generating an ROI of 195%. Unidragon utilized a ready-made Shopify integration module to implement Mindbox and hired a developer […]
ROI 807%: Cascade Campaigns, Automated Campaigns, Pop-ups, and the FOAM Loyalty Program
FOAM is an online cosmetics store with delivery in Eastern Europe and a beauty store. It offers premium niche brands with a strong reputation and boosts new local cosmetics developers.
Company size.
70.000 customers in the database
Goals
Manage communications in a single windowIncrease email channel revenueIncrease website conversionIncrease the subscriber base
Solutions
We switched to the marketing automation platformWe conducted an RFM analysis to personalize bulk and launch trigger campaigns and initiated cascade campaignsWe launched stories on the website, data-collecting pop-ups, and personalized widgetsWe launched an omnichannel loyalty program
Results
ROI 807%18.9% — the average share of email channel revenue in total revenue9.6% — the average share of trigger campaigns revenue in total revenue
IT stack.
ERP, Marketing Automation Platform
Previous platform.
9 months
Noteworthy features
We launched recommendations of related products based on their active ingredients
The following case study is from Mindbox, the original brand behind Maestra’s technology
FOAM marketing specialists were using three different services only to send emails. At the same time, the way the emails were designed left much to be desired, analytics were scattered across different systems, and the campaign preparation required the constant participation of developers. The plan was to launch a loyalty program and personalize the website, which would lead to an inevitable increase in the number of services used.
To avoid this issue, FOAM decided to implement a marketing automation platform. As a result of the integration, the company has been able to achieve the following:
- Marketing and developer teams now spend less time on tasks;
- Customers are segmented based on frequency and recency of purchases (after an RFM analysis was carried out);
- An automation map was created including non-standard automated campaigns — e.g., a reminder that a shampoo the customer had purchased would soon run out, or that the customer would need to buy sunscreen to give their vitamin A a boost;
- The website was personalized, an ETA timer was added for deliveries and a free delivery counter was added to the cart;
- An omnichannel loyalty program was launched.
We chose Mindbox because the platform allowed us to create complex campaigns and prepare all emails in a single interface. At the same time, the campaigns look absolutely amazing.
Unified analytics is also important for us. Sometimes, within the same campaign, we send both emails and text messages. Previously all the messages were sent from different services, and it was impossible to evaluate the results of the campaign in one report. However, now we can do it.
In addition, we planned to launch a loyalty program, we liked the fact that Mindbox would fully cover this project as well.
Unified analytics is also important for us. Sometimes, within the same campaign, we send both emails and text messages. Previously all the messages were sent from different services, and it was impossible to evaluate the results of the campaign in one report. However, now we can do it.
In addition, we planned to launch a loyalty program, we liked the fact that Mindbox would fully cover this project as well.
Results
-
807%ROI of marketing automation
-
18.9%Average share of email channel revenue in total revenue
-
9.6%Average revenue share of trigger emails in total revenue
ROI 807%
To calculate the ROI, we took data from January to September 2021. We have not disclosed the figures at FOAM’s request. Calculation formula:
807% — ROI from the Mindbox platform. This means that each dollar invested in the platform brings FOAM $8.
18.9% — the average share of email channel revenue relative to the total revenue
Data from the “Mindbox Summary report on campaigns,” Last-click attribution
9.6% — the average share of revenue from trigger campaigns in total revenue
Data from the “Mindbox Summary report on campaigns,” Last-click attribution
For us, Mindbox is not just software, but a ready-made comprehensive business solution. For example, during its implementation, we were not given access to basic functionalities, but a huge list of already well-thought campaigns to run. We could try each of them every day. Thanks to this approach, we began to launch tools that we hadn’t even thought about, such as pop-ups.
Our customer success manager, Antonina Volchenko, always helps us with our projects. It takes her and our marketing specialist just a few days, and sometimes hours, to sort out tasks. Mindbox’s support also responds promptly. It’s a pity that they don’t work on weekends.
The only disadvantage I can think of is a lack of ready-made solutions for all the ideas we have. For example, we would like to add a choice of a favorite product for customers, however, the platform cannot do this. Then we simplified the idea to the customer’s favorite brand choice. There was no ready-made function for it either, but our manager, Antonina, consulted with colleagues and suggested a manual solution. It is important for us to find the solution for our task, not just to put up with the fact that there is no ready-made solution.
Our customer success manager, Antonina Volchenko, always helps us with our projects. It takes her and our marketing specialist just a few days, and sometimes hours, to sort out tasks. Mindbox’s support also responds promptly. It’s a pity that they don’t work on weekends.
The only disadvantage I can think of is a lack of ready-made solutions for all the ideas we have. For example, we would like to add a choice of a favorite product for customers, however, the platform cannot do this. Then we simplified the idea to the customer’s favorite brand choice. There was no ready-made function for it either, but our manager, Antonina, consulted with colleagues and suggested a manual solution. It is important for us to find the solution for our task, not just to put up with the fact that there is no ready-made solution.
What has changed with the introduction of the marketing automation platform?
Mindbox integration with our ERP took place over two months. We started using the platform in March, and we were using it to manage campaigns by May.
The introduction of the platform made it easier to plan campaigns because now we communicate with customers from a single window and a marketing specialist can send emails without a programmer and a layout designer using ready-made templates and a visual email message builder. When we first used the platform, we were scared of its complex interface, but I know that it is being updated now. So, we look forward to seeing the results!
Since all the data is stored in a single system, we now have unified analytics. However, at the moment we don’t have all the reports that we need, and some of the existing ones may glitch. That being said, the Mindbox manager always helps to solve such problems.
The introduction of the platform made it easier to plan campaigns because now we communicate with customers from a single window and a marketing specialist can send emails without a programmer and a layout designer using ready-made templates and a visual email message builder. When we first used the platform, we were scared of its complex interface, but I know that it is being updated now. So, we look forward to seeing the results!
Since all the data is stored in a single system, we now have unified analytics. However, at the moment we don’t have all the reports that we need, and some of the existing ones may glitch. That being said, the Mindbox manager always helps to solve such problems.
Before the platform was implemented
After the platform was implemented
Bulk, automated, and transactional emails were sent from three different systems. There was a separate service for text messages.
Emails and text messages are sent from a single window.
The emails looked different because of the new layout. It was difficult to make automated emails look nice, although this is critical for the beauty sphere.
All brand communications are in a uniform style.
Emails and text messages were prepared with the help of layout specialists and programmers.
Campaigns are prepared without developers. If the text and images are ready, it takes 10 minutes to prepare and send an email campaign.
There was no single analytics source. The data had to be collected from different services.
Unified analytics. Even if a campaign took place in both email and SMS channels, its results can be evaluated in one report.
Active referral program for purchasers. The loyalty program was only a plan.
Launched a loyalty program.
How to segment the audience of bulk email campaigns
Bulk campaigns include news, useful articles, and promotional materials. At the same time, the customers receive no more than four emails per week. If they made an order or received a series of trigger emails, they are excluded from bulk campaigns, which prevents them from unsubscribing. Customers are segmented based on RFM analysis. They are evaluated based on the recency and frequency of their purchases, their average order value, as well as their interaction with emails. Periodically, different content is sent to active users and those who do not open emails. For example, we send news to active users, while churned users receive promo codes and personal recommendations. Those who have not responded to communications for a very long time are placed on stop lists and excluded from campaigns.
An email with a discount and a survey
This was sent to customers who had made an order in the last six months, but did not place another one in the past three months:
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
19.5%
3.1%
0.1%
Customers are also segmented by region. The residents of large cities are sent content related to the beauty store, such as news and special promotions.
Invitation to an in-store party
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
20.4%
1.7%
0.01%
An email about a discount for used packages
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
17.6%
0.4%
0.1%
How to use product recommendations in bulk email campaigns?
Almost all campaigns use product recommendations.
A/B test of product recommendations
Email with recommendations:
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
13.3%
0.8%
0,1%
Email without recommendations:
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
12.9%
0.6%
0,01%
We used recommendation widgets when we were working with the previous service, so we have something to compare it with. Mindbox makes the widgets look more beautiful and fit seamlessly into the design of the website. We look at the click map and follow the reports. We are very satisfied with how the widgets work. I like that they are easy to add and remove, I can experiment and not waste a lot of resources.
Recommendation widgets can’t be added to emails aimed at focusing on a particular brand or new products.
An email regarding new brands in the store
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
21.5%
1.4%
0.1%
An email regarding discounts on “Don’t touch my skin” brand
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
18.5%
2.7%
0.3%
We create all emails in the Mindbox campaign builder. We have prepared templates with different widgets such as products, product recommendations, and the number of points available in the loyalty program. Therefore, I prepare emails myself and it takes no time.
It’s a little inconvenient that we can’t drag a finished email from one campaign to another. For example, we tried a bulk campaign and then copied it to another campaign as a trigger with only one click. Now we have to do this by saving the campaign as a template. To be honest, it’s not very convenient.
It’s a little inconvenient that we can’t drag a finished email from one campaign to another. For example, we tried a bulk campaign and then copied it to another campaign as a trigger with only one click. Now we have to do this by saving the campaign as a template. To be honest, it’s not very convenient.
How to talk about promotions in cascade campaigns?
Big sales are held from time to time. For example, in August and September, they were stylized for music festivals. At this time, customers received email communications almost every day. Those who did not open email were “caught up” with text messages:
An email regarding the Beauty Rhythm Fest promotion
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
14.4%
1.7%
0.2%
Text message regarding the Beauty Rhythm Fest promotion
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
15.6%
0.5%
The SMS channel was initially connected for transactional communications: registration and login on the website, as well as order information. The phone number is the main identifier of the customer.
Over time, we began to use it for cascade campaigns in large promotions and automated campaigns for birthdays, with an abandoned cart, and for reactivating “sleeping customers”. That is, we used to send only emails, and now, if a person doesn’t respond to an email, they receive a text message.
We do not have a very large database of valid contacts with a subscription to SMS-informing yet. However, the SMS channel has been doing quite well.
Over time, we began to use it for cascade campaigns in large promotions and automated campaigns for birthdays, with an abandoned cart, and for reactivating “sleeping customers”. That is, we used to send only emails, and now, if a person doesn’t respond to an email, they receive a text message.
We do not have a very large database of valid contacts with a subscription to SMS-informing yet. However, the SMS channel has been doing quite well.
How the automation map was improved
Welcome series. Previously, the store had a short welcome series consisting of two emails: DOI and emails with a 10% discount. Now the sequence has been significantly expanded and made more comprehensive:
The welcome series was transferred into a workflow. This is quite convenient as we can see what is actually happening at each stage. And it’s clear without a description — anyone can go into the workflow and get a rough understanding of what it is and when it should be sent.
We have made a series of five emails with discount offers, where the discount amount depends on the actions of the customer. For example, if the recipient did not open the first email with a discount, they will receive a bigger discount. And if they opened the email, but did not place an order, they will receive a story about the range of products and loyalty program, pushing for the first purchase. After some time, a reminder will be sent informing them that the discount is going to expire.
The series also solves another problem. It weeds out bots that register on the website. In order not to accumulate a dead database, it displays all users who have not performed a single action within two weeks after registration in a separate segment. We then simply have to delete them.
We have made a series of five emails with discount offers, where the discount amount depends on the actions of the customer. For example, if the recipient did not open the first email with a discount, they will receive a bigger discount. And if they opened the email, but did not place an order, they will receive a story about the range of products and loyalty program, pushing for the first purchase. After some time, a reminder will be sent informing them that the discount is going to expire.
The series also solves another problem. It weeds out bots that register on the website. In order not to accumulate a dead database, it displays all users who have not performed a single action within two weeks after registration in a separate segment. We then simply have to delete them.
Double-Opt-In (DOI) email
This is sent to confirm registration:
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
62.6%
44.1%
11.1%
Reminder to confirm subscription
This is sent two days after an unconfirmed subscription:
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
29.7%
4.7%
0.4%
An email with a 10% discount and recommendations
This is sent if the user left their contact details in the pop-up on the website:
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
75.3%
12.7%
3.3%
Abandoned category and product view, and abandoned cart. We launched campaigns for an abandoned category and product view, as well as an abandoned cart. Product recommendations help to return customers to the website.
Abandoned product browse
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
36%
2.7%
0.2%
Abandoned cart
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
34.8%
5.9%
1.7%
Abandoned product category view
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
38.4%
2.4%
0.2%
Related products recommendations. The customers’ purchases say a lot about them, and FOAM uses this knowledge to make a suitable offer. This means that if the customer has sensitive skin, they will be offered specialized products for this issue.
We have extensive expertise related to our products. When we know what the customer has bought, we can fairly accurately advise the related product. For example, depending on the active ingredient in the purchased product, we recommend additional care products to complement it.
An email regarding sun protection
This is sent to those who bought cosmetics that contain acids, vitamin C, and vitamin A:
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
31.5%
1.8%
0.1%
An email regarding hair accessories
This is sent to those who bought hair care products:
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
33.8%
2%
0.1%
A reminder that the purchased product is running out. We can roughly calculate how quickly certain products run out. For example, shampoo is consumed in 60 days. This information was added to the product feed, from where it gets into Mindbox. Then we set up a trigger campaign. When a person buys a product, the system waits, and then seven days before the expected date when the product is supposed to run out, it sends an email with an offer to buy it again.
It took us about a month to analyze the products, determine the time they run out with the help of the IT department, and ultimately add this information to the feeds. It took Mindbox about a week to set up the automated campaign.
Reminder that the shampoo will end soon
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
42.4%
3.3%
0.8%
Reactivation. Based on RFM analysis, the audience was divided into groups by frequency, recency, and order value. Each group received an email reminding them about the brand and offering them a 15% discount:
An email with reactivation discount
Results in the “Customers that are churning” segment:
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
27.4%
6.7%
0.3%
Results in the “Lost regular customers” segment:
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
22.9%
3.3%
0.3%
How the website was personalized
Stories, pop-ups, embedded blocks, and widgets are launched on the FOAM website in order to collect customer data and increase conversion. Product recommendations are used both in email campaigns and in the online store. “Wheel of Fortune” for collecting email addresses. Customers who are not subscribed to the store’s communications see the “Wheel of Fortune” pop-up. At the same time, it does not distract from purchases as it does not appear on the product page and in the cart.
-
9,7thousand customers have left email addresses in 2 months
-
8,8%pop-up conversion
A pop-up for collecting the date of birth. When we launched an automated campaign with a birthday promo code, it became necessary to collect the customers’ dates of birth. Therefore, customers with a subscription were displayed the following pop-up:
-
3thousand customers have indicated their birthday in 2 months
-
19,5%pop-up conversion rate
In the future, we plan to launch more pop-ups to collect data about customers’ favorite products and favorite brands in order to offer loyalty program participants additional privileges when buying these products. Also, it takes into account customer preferences in personal recommendations.
Stories. In stories, we talk about promotions and products, we observe active ingredients and the problems of customers that these products can solve.
Now all users see the story, so the conversion per click is low — about 0.2%. Stories that contain recommendations of specific products for the customer’s issues show the best indicators. We plan to personalize them over time, i.e. customize the display to new users or highlight another segment in targeting.
ETA timer. Fast delivery is one of the advantages of the store. Orders placed before 16:00 will be delivered on the same day within the city. Therefore, customers from the specific cities see how much time is left to place an order to receive it today. Other users don’t see the timer.
Free shipping counter. Delivery in the store is free if the order value exceeds $80. Embedded blocks and widgets help customers understand how many products they need to add to the cart to get free delivery.
Product recommendations. Embedded blocks and widgets with recommendations are added on the main page, in the product card, and in the cart.
I like that recommendations can be customized. We can select a specific product category or exclude something we don’t need. This helps to make the selections more thoughtful.
Why is the loyalty program being restarted?
Previously, FOAM only had a referral program for purchasers. One of the reasons for switching to Mindbox is the opportunity to develop our unique loyalty program. As a result, we launched a tiered point loyalty program. When buying, the customer receives points that they can start spending in a week. Points can be used to pay for up to 99% of the purchase. Additionally, customers received discounts on their birthday and on their favorite products. At the same time, the loyalty program is omnichannel — the customer can get bonus points in the beauty store, and spend them in the online store, and vice versa.
An email regarding the accrual of points in the loyalty program
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
50.8%
8%
0.8%
An email regarding the transition to a new level in the loyalty program
Open rate
Click rate
Conversion rate (measured using last-click attribution)
53.7%
10.4%
0.9%
We tried to fill the loyalty program with all possible bonuses and privileges and overdid it.
Six months later, we evaluated the results. We compared how many points were awarded and how much was spent. It turned out that customers did not actively use the loyalty program. Then we ordered its audit and found out that it was too complicated for customers. They don’t understand what to do and when to get bonus points. We talked a lot about this in our communications, but in the end we only confused customers.
Now we are restarting the loyalty program. It will be a discount loyalty program. We hope that the discount that customers can get here and now will work better than the bonus points available in a week. Additionally, we will reward customers with a small cashback of 1-2% and bonus points for activities, such as product reviews.
How do we plan to develop direct marketing?
- Run NPS surveys in email campaigns to track customer satisfaction.
- Modify recommendation widgets in the cart, and make them more personalized. Add recommendations to the blog. As a rule, authors mention products in articles, but they also want to add recommendations that will offer related products.
- Create more personalized pop-ups, for example with related products or information regarding promotions. Add a warning that the product is running out of stock.
- Redo the promo page on the website. Currently, this is a set of banners. We are going to make a full-fledged page and automate shares using our ERP. By adding a promotional product to the cart, the customer will see a pop-up with an offer to perform a target action (add the same product for the second time or another product of this brand) and receive a discount or gift.
- Launch a bot on the website that will ask questions and recommend products based on the answers.
- Restart the loyalty program so that it motivates customers to return.